Home Turntable Phono CD Pre Speaker Multi Pre HT |
HT |
As I've already documented most of my audio system in mind numbing detail I thought I might as well do the same for the video side of things. If you're wondering about the title of this page it's because I still don't think I have a "home theatre" as such as I see that term applying more to creating in your home a smaller version of a commercial theatre. A dedicated room complete in just about every aspect with stepped seating, carpeted walls, curtains everywhere, auto dimming lighting, maybe even a foyer, a snack bar complete with popcorn machine and everything else you'd find in a proper theatre.
And by proper I'm thinking more of an old fashioned picture theatre and not that blight on the entertainment landscape otherwise known as a multiplex cinema complex. Home theatres do exist and you see some rather magnificent ones in magazines or on TV shows devoted to people who have more money than they know of things to spend it on. You might even be lucky enough to know someone that has one and invites you around to watch a movie or two from time to time.
However what I have is a more or less normal home with a lounge/living room into which I've squeezed a BIG screen (emphasis on BIG for reasons that will become apparent later) and a sound system. But it is a room that's used for other things, so not really a home theatre but simply a pretty decent audio/video system.
Sources |
There are multiple digital sources for the system. Standard Definition (SD) and High Definition (HD) Free To Air (FTA) digital TV and SD/HD Foxtel digital, both via an IQ2 Set Top Box (STB) and having played with a few PVR's I must say that I'm very impressed with this unit. Now if they'd only give us some more HD channels and stop charging us so much it would be perfect. There is also of course Blu-ray, HD DVD and DVD sources. From the IQ2 I'm currently running HDMI for video as well as optical for audio as the IQ2 still won't output multi-channel audio via HDMI. All the other sources are connected via HDMI to the Audio Video Receiver (AVR) and the HDMI output of it feeds via a two way HDMI splitter to a HD Plasma screen (46" 800A series Panasonic) for normal TV viewing as well as to the projector.
I also had access for some time to a digital VHS VCR, a JVC HM-DH30000V and a box full of 1080i D-Theater tapes. Even though this was connected via analog component and the projector is scaling the 1080i down to 720p it's still clearly the best picture I've ever seen on a home theatre setup. The detail, colour saturation, lack of background noise and film like smoothness is truly beautiful to watch. Not that I'm saying 576i DVD upsampled to 720p isn't good, it is. In fact I've never seen DVD look this good, it's just that 1080i D-Theater is clearly better. Lets hope we get HiDef DVD soon and that the quality is as good as this.
And the good news is that it's better, as we found out during a couple of HiDef DVD demo nights we had recently (May 2006). The DVD player was an imported USA model Toshiba HD-A1 and the first night used a Sony 1292 CRT and then we had a night here using my 720p LCD followed by a Sony VW100 (aka "Ruby"). We watched clips from Last Samurai, Serenity, Phantom of the Opera, Apollo 13, Million Dollar Baby and then most of Goodfellas. The quality on all three projectors was very good and so much better than standard DVD, the standout being the VW100 which was just stunning. We now all await Sony to get their act together and release Blu-ray.
Which they did but sadly at the time of writing (May 2007) the supply of suitable standalone Blu-ray players in Australia is lagging way behind the rest of the World. We have a choice of two and both of them priced at way more than most people are willing to pay. The good news is that with the release of the 1.80 firmware update for the PlayStation 3 (PS3) which added the much needed 1080/24p output as well as upscaling of standard DVD to 1080/50p we finally got a decent player. So obviously I bought one and I've even heard rumours that you can also play games on it. And as good as it was as a Blu-ray and DVD player it was eventually replaced with a standalone player, in this case a Panasonic BD35. Which has since been retired and I'm now using an Oppo BDP-83.
Unfortunately because some movie studios aren't keeping up with what most people want to buy and watch (Blu-ray), I've also had to buy a Toshiba (what other brand is there) HD DVD player. An XE1 (XA2 in the USA) that despite being very solidly built and putting out a very nice picture is seriously clunky to use. Talk about slow to boot up, load and play or in general respond to any command from the remote. And what's the story with all the blue lights, shouldn't they be red (or even more correctly brown).
Projector |
November must be projector upgrade time for me as I've just taken delivery of a new Sony VPL-VW80 projector to replace the previous VW50 (Pearl). So far very happy as it puts out a beautiful picture and is a major step up from the VW50/60.
Preliminary settings |
To be honest I haven't spent that much time trying to tweak this thing to get the last bit of performance out of it.
Too busy watching movies so apart from sorting out the basic settings it hasn't taken much to get the Gamma and grey scale tracking to where they should be.
Dynamic Iris - On all previous Sony projectors I've always preferred the less agressive Auto 2 mode for the DI but I've got to say that on the VW80 Auto 1 works the best.
Probably because Sony limits the "gearing" of the Dynamic Iris to around 5:1 and this is a 12k - 15k native on/off contrast ratio panel.
You do have to get the Gamma curve right though.
Motionflow - Film Projection (Dark Frame Insertion- DFI) : Apart from Off you have three settings for this.
Mode 1 inserts blank full black frames and therefore turns Motion Enhance off but it also results in a rather dark image and to be honest I wonder why anyone would want to use this mode.
Mode 2 and Mode 3 both work with Motion Enhance and insert gamma corrected film frames and Mode 3 gives the brightest image.
I've stopped using DFI as it does reduce the contrast ratio, causes a visible "flicker" in the image and doesn't improve motion that much anyway as the Sony's are better than most in regard to motion blur, sample and hold artifacts and such things.
I do however use Mode 3 for some films, like old black and white ones that have had all traces of their heritage removed during digital remastering.
Motionflow - Motion Enhance (Frame Interpolation - FI) : Off, Low and High are the three settings available and whilst the purists will tell you that you shouldn't use any sort of Frame Interpolation for film based material I must admit I rather like it.
Yes it does create the occasional artifact but these are rare and it certainly doesn't make film look like video.
What it does do is smooth the image, reduce judder and also reduce all sorts of other de-interlacing induced artifacts like shimmering on sharp edges during pans and in my opinion doing more good than harm.
Perhaps this is due to not having to have watched 60hz 3:2 pulldown induced judder all my life for film based material having grown up with 50hz PAL which is probably smoother than 24 frame film anyway.
Strangely high works best with 50hz (PAL) material and Low is more suited to 24p material, and yes it does appear to work with 24p even though some will tell you that it doesn't.
Gamma : I'm using slightly modified custom gamma curve for Gamma 5 which starts at 2.2 and then rises uniformally to 2.4 at 20% stimulas and then stays more or less flat from then on (difficult to achieve with a DI).
With a bit of work in ImageDirector you can get all three colours to track together across the entire range, especially at the bottom end which helps your grey scale tracking and ensures good shadow detail.
RCP (Real Color Processing) : Yeah okay it's no CMS but with minor adjustments and the use of the main Colour control you can get a pretty good CIE chart with very good linearity for all saturation levels.
User 1
TV SportStandard [1]
DVD PALUser 2
DVD PALCinema [1]
Blu-ray 24pUser3
Blu-ray 24p Cinema Black Advanced Iris Auto 1 Auto 1 Auto 1 Auto 1 Auto 1 Sensitivity Fast Fast Fast Fast Fast Lamp Control Low Low Low Low Low Motionflow Film Projection Off Off Off Off Off Motion Enhance Off High High Low Low Contrast 90 90 90 90 90 Brightness 48 48 48 48 48 Colour 45 45 45 45 45 Hue 50 50 50 50 50 Color Temp Custom 2 Custom 3 Custom 3 Custom 3 Custom 3 Temperature 7500ºK 6500ºK 6500ºK 6500ºK 6500ºK Red Gain +2 -4 -4 -4 -4 Green Gain 0 0 0 0 0 Blue Gain -1 +2 +2 +2 +2 Red Bias -10 -14 -14 -14 -14 Green Bias 0 0 0 0 0 Blue Bias -8 -10 -10 -10 -10 Sharpness 40 40 40 40 40 Expert Settings MPEG NR Mosquito Low Low Low Low Low MPEG NR Block Low Low Low Low Low Film Mode Auto1 Auto1 Auto1 - - Black Level Adj Low Low Low Low Low Gamma Adjust Gamma 5 Gamma 5 Gamma 5 Gamma 5 Gamma 5 X.V. Color Off Off Off Off Off Color Space Wide Wide Wide Wide Wide Notes on the settings
RCP User2 / 6500ºK
Red Yellow Green
Cyan Blue Magenta
Colour +2 -3 +5 +2 +6 0 Hue +5 0 +5 0 0 -5
Projector calibration |
I use an Eye-One Display2 Colorimeter, the excellent and free French ColorHCFR software, their test pattern DVD as well as the AVS HD 709 Rec. 709 encoded HD video test patterns disk. Apart from some minor installation glitches like having to install the Eye-One Match 3 software into the default folder because it wouldn't find some of it's files if installed elsewhere, it was all pretty simple. You also have to copy EyeOne.dll from this folder to the ColorHCFR folder so it will recognise the Display2 sensor.
Why the UPS? |
One very windy and stormy day whilst I was using my computer the power at first flickered a couple of times, just long enough for everything in the house that didn't have a battery backup to reset themselves and then it went off completely. It didn't come back on for about five minutes and even then they were a couple more device resetting flickers.
At the time I thought, gee I'm glad that every PC in the house is connected to a UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply). And then I started to think about what would happen if the projector was on when the power went off, to come back on shortly afterwards or not. Very shortly after that I bought another UPS and that now powers the projector.
Globes don't like "hot starts", that is being turned off and then shortly after being turned on again. They also like to be cooled down which is why the fan continues to run for a minute or two after you turn the projector off via the remote control (and why you should never turn a projector off at the wall socket or pull it's power lead out).
I'm using a 600VA UPS which should run the projector for long enough to turn it off and allow the proper cool down period. As a bonus it also includes surge protection and voltage stabilization (AVR) which protects the projector and more importantly the globe from wild variations in the mains voltage. At a cost which is a fraction of that of a new globe and available at every computer shop every home theatre system should have at least one.
The screen |
The screen is a 2300mm wide top of the range LP Morgan Galleria with Novares fabric in Scope (2.35:1) ratio.
The screen hangs from the ceiling by two lead counter weighted wires that pass over a pulley system.
When not in use it's raised to the 3300mm (11ft) ceiling and when required its lowered, so it's a pull down but fixed frame screen!
I'm currently using what some would unkindly call "the poor mans CIH method" in that I don't use an additional anamorphic lens to stretch 2.35:1 images sideways after first scaling them to full panel height.
This works rather well for me because apart from a few minor adjustments to frame images correctly I don't do that much zooming.
The reason being is that I watch very little TV on the projector, the odd sports program and I don't play games on it at all, so that just leaves movies and most of them are 2.35 - 2.40:1 so that's the configuration the system stays in most of the time.
But to make switching between 1.78:1 and 2.35:1 as easy as possible the projector is placed so that at zero zoom it fills the screen height for 1.78:1 material.
So to frame 1.85:1, 2.35:1, 2.40:1 or anything in between all I do is zoom in, tweak the focus, maybe a bit of lens shift and perhaps even a bit of left and right panel blanking to stop overspill on for example 2.40:1 material after adjusting it for full screen height.
Audio processing for all sources is taken care of by a Sony STR-DA5500ES 7.1 channel AVR.
It supports all the current audio formats including DTS-HD Master Audio and High Resolution Audio, Dolby Digital Plus and TrueHD, 7.1 Linear PCM and DSD and has 6 HDMI 1.3 inputs as well as 7.1 analog inputs.
With Faroudja DCDi processing it will scale analog video sources to 1080p but sadly not HDMI sources.
As I'm effectively running a 9.1 system even with Dolby Pro Logic encoded 2.0 (digital telly, Foxtel digital, etc), 5.1 or 7.1 material (DVD, HD DVD and Blu-ray) I use the AFD Enhanced Surround mode with PLIIx rear decoding.
If Sony range of AVRs do have a weakness it would be their power amplifiers which with all channels driven hard are a tad lacking in power.
The processing capabilities and pre-amplifier quality however of the 5500ES are excellent so I'm only it as a pre-amplifier/processor with the line level pre outs being fed into one set of inputs of a multi channel analog buffered passive pre-amplifier.
From there the signals are distributed to the various active crossover, amplifier and speaker combinations.
All the speakers are run as "Large", so no bass redirection to the Subs or other speakers as they were all designed to be full range and can certainly handle anything that's thrown at them even at very loud listening levels.
To enhance dialog, as in being able to clearly hear it even when people (in the movie) are whispering I drive the centre channel slightly louder, a couple of db and also apply some equalization, a slight amount of boost for midrange frequencies centred around 1khz.
The sound system
Audio processing for all digital sources is taken care of by a Sony STR-DA5500ES 7.1 channel AV Receiver. It supports all the current audio formats including DTS-HD Master Audio and High Resolution Audio, Dolby Digital Plus and TrueHD, 7.1 Linear PCM and DSD. 7.1 analog inputs, lots of digital inputs including 6 HDMI inputs and 2 HDMI outs which is real handy when you're running two displays.
Left and right front speakers |
The left and right front speakers for surround sound / home theatre audio are in fact my main stereo left and right speakers that I listen to for two channel audio. Or is it the other way around? Anyway they're big and of sufficient quality to do both jobs. No further description is needed as they are fully described elsewhere on this site in Active speaker system.
The system easily dwarfs Barry the bear and his friend Stanley who have been placed in the picture for the purpose of illustrating scale assuming you're ignoring everything else in the background that may give you some kind of a hint. Barry has been known to climb the speakers and then absail down to the floor. "Its a bloody long way to the top but well worth the climb and the view is magnificent" says the adventurous Barry.
The "balls" serve no useful purpose at all that I can see. Probably just some Darlec (can't say Dalek else the BBC gets cranky) DNA that got in there somehow. That's why I call them Eleven (house brand, 1 more than 10, Spinal Tap, etc) D4 (Digital 4 way) Darlecs.
Centre channel speakers |
I say speakers because there are two cabinets and seven drivers in all,one cabinet above the screen and the other below it. Both are three way and the mid point between the mid range and tweeter in each box aligns with the centre of the screen, horizontally. The reason for this configuration is that as both are fed with the same signal the apparent output is mid way between them, which is the centre of the screen, vertically. In fact the top box is driven slightly harder than the bottom one to compensate for it being closer to the top of the screen than the bottom box is to the bottom of the screen. This moves the acoustic centre upwards to align with the main left and right speakers.
The top box has four drivers, a pair of Morel NeoLin MW267 7" bass drivers, a Vifa M10MD39-08 3" mid range and a Vifa D27TG45-06 1" tweeter. The bottom box is the same but uses only one MW267 7" bass driver. There are no ports. All the boxes are sealed. There are plans to replace the mid range and tweeters with MG10MD09-08 and D2905/970000. I have the drivers to do this but just haven't gotten around to doing it yet.
The speakers are active/passive with a two way active crossover at 600hz and a two way passive crossover at 3000hz. The three bass drivers are driven directly and the mid/tweeter pairs via the passive crossover. This requires five amplifier channels and I'm currently using a Sony QS Series STR-DB900 receiver as this has the required set of 5.1 analog inputs and six 100W per channel digital amplifiers. It's a very clean sounding amplifier with a lot of detail which is handy as the centre channel does handle most of the dialog.
Some would claim that you can't use two centre channel speakers because of diffraction/lobing/interference patterns caused by drivers spaced a distance apart and outputting the same, in this case monaural signal. To understand why this isn't actually a problem you have to look at the polar response of two drivers and the interference pattern they create. For two drivers spaced less than one wavelength apart at the crossover point and assuming there are no driver offset, crossover phase issues and that the crossover is in fact working correctly then the polar response is rather simple.
You have a fairly wide central lobe (a peak in the output) at 90º and two lobes of lesser magnitude either side at about 40º. As the driver spacing is increased all that happens is that the number of lobes increases but for the lobes within a 45º spread either side of perpendicular their magnitude is about the same and the troughs between them are no deeper than the simple three lobe pattern. At very wide driver spacing, as in using one speaker below the screen and another above it you still get a main central lobe at 90º but it is more pronounced and not as wide.
Note to me: Add some graphics.
This could be a possible problem except for the fact that in my system the vertical mid point of the two sets of drivers is 1200mm off the floor and with my seating this is just slightly above head height.
This means that for everybody that's seated (as you would be when watching a film) they're getting maximum driver output and a flat frequency response.
Moving your head up and down even a fair amount doesn't change this but obviously if you were to stand or lay on the floor you would notice changes in the frequency response and if you really wanted to show that there were variations in the frequency response when using two centre speakers you could go to these extremes.
One other thing to consider is that because the side lobes (in the vertical plane) are of much lesser magnitude with widely spaced drivers you could argue that you're getting less secondary reflections of the floor and/or ceiling and this is a good thing as it improves the time coherence of the signal.
And on that very subject, yes there is a path length difference between the two sets of drivers but this is an active speaker system we're talking about and I'm using a six channel AVR to drive it.
An AVR that includes speaker distance settings which corrects this sort of problem rather nicely.
Which leaves us with the horizontal driver layout and it not matching the vertical configuration of the main left and right speakers and why this isn't an error or a problem.
Referring above to the paragraph about drivers spaced less than one wavelength apart at the crossover frequency and noting the three lobe polar response pattern with the rather wide central lobe.
So wide in fact that the angle between the -6db points on either side is about 45º and taking into account the vertical dispersion pattern already discussed, unless you're sitting way off axis you're not only getting a flat frequency response but one that matches the main speakers.
Measurements of the dual centre channel in my system show no greater a variance in the frequency response across the entire seating area than when using just one (or the other) single speaker system.
Obviously you're mileage may vary in using two centre speakers and you may not have the luxury of a complex and equalised active crossover and flexible AVR to drive it all but it can be made to work very well indeed.
Apart from placing a centre speaker in the centre of and behind an acoustically transparent screen (which has it's own problems and drawbacks) it is the only way to ensure that all centre channel information comes from where it should be coming from, which is the centre of the screen.
And assuming your left and right front speakers are also correctly aligned with the screen, that is with the tweeter and/or perhaps the tweeter and midrange drivers aligned vertically with the centre of the screen then all pans will work and sound as they were intended to.
Yeak okay the photo's a bit dark and it's a tad hard to see the drivers so I've highlighted the mid range and top end ones with yellow dots. The red lines join the mid points between them which is the apparent acoustic source for vocals and directional information for both the centre channel speakers and the main left and right speakers.
*New photo required*
The top centre channel speaker with the screen raised. When it's lowered the top of the screen sits just below the woofers. A flipped image of this picture if you like. Below the speaker is a two hinged panel absorption/diffusing screen shown in it's closed position. The gap between the panels is deliberate as is the angle they form. The panels cover the TV when not in use and improve imaging for stereo and multi channel music by creating an acoustically dead area between the left and right speakers. They consist of 18mm MDF covered by 12mm compressed cotton wadding which is then covered by 50mm square and triangular blocks of up to 50mm thick built up from layers of 5mm thick rabbit fur felt.
The Sony STR-DB900 and crossover sit in a small rack below the lower centre channel speaker.
Front effects speakers |
After hearing a demo of a Yamaha 7.1 system several years ago I decided that front effects speakers were a useful addition to any surround sound system when used for movie soundtracks. Yamaha pioneered 7.1 and these days have extended it to 9.1 and even 11.2 in the case of the RX-Z11. THX have a 10.2 system which users three high front effects speakers, left, right and a centre speaker they refer to as "god".
Front effects speakers are placed as high and as wide in the room as possible. In the top left and right front corners of the room is a good place for them. Reflections of the rear and side walls and ceiling caused by this placement aren't a problem at all and probably help achieve the desired result.
The extra two channels to drive front effects speakers don't really exist on 5.1, 6.1 or even 7.1 encoded material but it isn't hard to fake it. All you need to do is take your existing front left and right signals, pass them through a high pass filter, isolate the out of phase components (what used to be called in the good old days of stereo, a "phase or width enhancer"), delay these a tad and feed what's left to a small stereo amplifier.
In this case two channels of a 70w per channel Yamaha DSP E-492 and then to a small pair of speakers that only need to handle from about 500hz upwards. Drivers used are Vifa M10MD39-08 3" mid range and a Vifa D27TG45-06 1" tweeter hooked up with via a modest two way passive crossover.
Front effects speakers add width and more importantly height to a room. They are most effective with soundtracks that have a lot of off screen activity going on. Jungle scenes, streetscapes and the like are simply amazing.
Probably the smallest speaker box I think I've ever built. Sealed of course. Mounted on a bass trap in the top corner of the room. Surprisingly effective.
Rear speakers |
The front left and right speakers have some serious horsepower. As do the centre channel speakers with their 7 drivers, 5 amplifiers and 500+ watt total output. I needed something at the rear of the room that not only sounded the same but could hold their own, so to speak. What I've ended up with is perhaps more than what's required but I figure that if you're going to go to the trouble of bolting speakers to a masonry wall or lifting roof sheets to get access to the rafters so you can mount threaded rod hangers then you might as well make them as big and heavy as you can.
With the advent of Blu-ray and it's 7.1 soundtracks and A/V receivers that can process 7.1 you now apparently need four rear surround speakers or at a pinch, three. The first pair (Surround) to the side and slightly to the rear of you at between 10º and 30º rear of where you sit and another pair or a single speaker (Surround Back) behind you. To take full advantage of the Cinema Studio EX modes the angle between each of these speakers should ideally be the same, so between 160/3 = 53º and 120/3 = 40º for four enclosures.
Surround speakers |
A three way sealed box system using a Morel NeoLin MW267 7" bass driver, a Vifa M10MD39-08 3" mid range and Vifa D27TG45-06 1" tweeter. Very solid construction using 38mm laminate MDF/Particle board panels for the sides and 50mm for the front and back. Like the centre channel system it's active/passive with an active 4th order Linkwitz/Riley at 600hz and a passive 2nd order filter at 3000hz. Like the other mid/top passive filters in the system, not that there are many, impedance correction and resonant frequency notch filters are included.
To drive the speakers I'm using four channels of a Sony QS Series STR-DB900 100 watt per channel digital amplifier, the same type that's used for the centre channel. The beauty of digital amplifiers, especially when directly connected to bass drivers as in an active system is the sheer depth and quality of the bass.
And no the photo isn't upside down, it's just that because I wanted to mount these as close to the ceiling as possible it was better to turn the speakers upside down. This gets the tweeters away from the ceiling to avoid reflections, brings the heights more into line with the rear surround speakers and gives better angles (and hence dispersion) to a seated audience. Not obvious in this photo but the enclosure is tilted down and inwards by about 45 degrees. Weighing in at nearly 20kgs they hang by chain to four mounting points from stainless steel ferrules and 8mm threaded rod fixed to 40mm angle iron which spans three ceiling joists.
Okay, so laying gear on its side is probably not the best arrangement but when space is tight you do the best you can and I'm rapidly running out of room. The black 1U rack case is the active crossover and on top of it is the Sony STR-DB900 digital amplifier (actually a full AVR but I'm only using it's amplifiers). It does keep the speaker leads short, to one speaker at least as mounting midway between the speakers and on the ceiling wasn't practical. The big red and green blotches on the active crossover are stick on labels that cover the LED's to dim them so they barely glow in the dark.
Surround back speakers |
A three way active system each powered by yet another 70w per channel Yamaha DSP E-492 amplifier. In case you're wondering what the story is with these amps, it's that I got a good deal on a few of them. These were a great little add on unit for two channel systems that provided Dolby Pro Logic decoding with three amplifiers to power the centre and rear channels. I'm only using the very good amplifier sections, rated at 60W but actually putting out 70W at the same distortion levels.
Drivers are Vifa PL26WR09-08 (OEM version of paper coned M26WR-09-08) 10" bass, Vifa M10MD39-08 3" mid range and a Vifa D27TG45-06 1" tweeter. All are mounted in sealed boxes. Front and back panels are 50mm, others are 38mm. Crossover points are 600hz and 3000hz and that's the crossover sitting on top of the amplifier, both of which are sitting on a shelf that's bolted to the wall.
They just appear to hang there like something that shouldn't but a look around the back reveals a very substantial welded steel bracket and five fixing points to the wall. The stepped enclosures are to reduce baffle effects and to also time align the drivers. The enclosures are also angled downwards and inwards enough to align them with a nominal centre of room seating position.
Low frequency effects speakers (subs) |
Every home theatre system needs a subwoofer or so the salesmen keep telling us. Not just to make up for any bass deficiencies your main speakers might have but to take full advantage of the .1 signal. But if you're going to have one, then why not have two. In fact why not have four spread around the room and this is exactly what I've done. For further reading on the use of multiple LFE drivers you could read the AES paper #5062 titled "Subwoofers: Optimum Number and Location" by Todd Welti.
At the front of the room are a pair of dual driver subwoofer which uses Peerless 831857 12" drivers each with its own enclosure and 125W amplifier. Both enclosures are sealed boxes, constructed from laminated 25mm MDF for 50mm wall thickness, heavily braced and damped and stuffed with long fibre wool at 48gm/litre. It's really two subwoofers, one sitting on top of the other that happen to be joined, rather than one subwoofer, in fact the Q's of both boxes are slightly different. Along the rear and one side wall are two additional subwoofers which use Vifa M26WR-09-08 10" drivers and the same 125W amplifiers. The enclosure is a standard double folded tapered transmission line.
Whilst each enclosure has an amplifier built into it there is no crossover, just a buffer. All six subwoofers are driven from a common control amplifier via three channels with adjustable levels and filtering.
I'm still a fan of transmission lines and people are generally impressed with the size of the things and tend to ask questions. You can achieve much the same result though with a much smaller low Q sealed box.
The story so far |
Just in case you're reading this and thinking that there sure are a lot of speakers and amplifiers in this room, well yes there are but it is a fully active 9.1 system. Anyway here's a summary of the current state of play...
29 Amplifiers (as in individual channels) total power 2600 watts [1], driving 37 Drivers (consisting of six 12", four 10", seven 7", ten 3" and ten 1") mounted in 14 Cabinets (speaker boxes).
[1] Actual watts RMS into 8 ohms at rated distortion levels but the effective power of active speaker systems is always higher than a single amplifier driving a multi speaker passive system. As a general rule for a three way active system you add the total power of the three amplifiers and then double it.
A normal lounge room |
Right at the start of this article I said I had a normal home with a more or less normal lounge/living area that I use for audio and video related activities as well as it's usual functions. Well I'm sticking to this story even though some people would say I have a far from normal home and that's apart from this room. It has been suggested that I'm heading into "bat cave" territory and whilst I think that's a slight exageration the room probably has gone way past the bounds of what some people, especially spouses, might consider reasonable.
In my defence though getting a decent picture or for that matter decent sound does require that some work be done to the room. No projector is ever going to achieve anything like it's true performance in a room with a white ceiling, light coloured walls, flooring and furnishings. This is especially true for absolute black levels, shadow detail and scenes with high contrast as any light reflected back from the room will degrade the image. The better the projector the more important all this becomes because the limitations of the room will simply drag it back to the same level of performance as a lesser machine.
Image depth or if you prefer "pop" as some people like to describe it is dependent on the ANSI (the ability to show something dark right next to something bright and maintain the contrast between them) and On/Off (the maximum output for an all white scene compared to the minimum output for an all black one) contrast of a projector with a fair bit of interplay between the two. In high APL (Average Picture Level) scenes (ie. bright) ANSI contrast is more important and in low APL scenes (dark) On/Off contrast becomes more important. Nothing kills either of them quicker than light bouncing back from the room and onto the screen. Light spill back onto the screen can also desaturate the colours so they appear washed out and not as vibrate as they could be.
Achieving excellent audio quality opens up a whole other can of worms with things such as getting the reverberation time right, taming first reflection points, controlling room modes and putting all the speakers in the right place. The most important aspect is of course the room shape and dimensions because if you get this right then it reduces the number or at least the severity of problems that you have to solve later. Luckily for us work by the likes of O.J. Bonello, M.M. Louden and others has made this a fairly simple process. The application of various acoustic treatments such as absorbent panels, diffusers and bass traps can then be used to bring the rooms acoustics up to an optimal level of performance.
This photo was taken during the day with lights on, the blinds open and has been further processed to increase the brightness. The room is a tad dark at the best of times and dominated by audio/video equipment. A lot of people, especially non audio/video enlightened ones when seeing the room for the first time are a bit lost for words.
Drawing of the room showing the positions of the video (pink), speakers (orange), subs (purple) and acoustic treatments (grey), mainly 500mm and 250mm cylindrical bass traps but also including flat panel diffusers. Some of the vertical bass traps run floor to ceiling for room mode control whilst others are purely to control reflections. The physical acoustic centre of the room, an equal distance from each of the five main speakers, in this case 3000mm, is in the middle of the seating area. Whilst you can correct electronically for speakers that are closer to you than they perhaps should be, there's nothing like having them all as far away as possible as it increases the size of the sweet spot so more people get good quality surround audio.
Walls are double solid brick, except the front and stub wall which are stud but filled with Rockwool and lined with 16mm FyreCheck plaster. In order to dampen the room somewhat and avoid a hard concrete box one entire brick wall (the left side one) is covered with a stud wall using 10mm Gyprock. The vertical studs are metal and only fixed top and bottom so the entire wall can flex. Floor is solid timber over concrete slab, windows are double glazed laminated glass.
It's a pretty big room at 6800mm x 5000mm (22.3ft x 16.4ft) and with a average ceiling height of 3100mm (10.2ft) that works out to be a tad over 100 m3 (3700 ft3) and that's before it opens out onto a 1600mm wide passageway. A good size for decent audio for reverberation, standing wave reduction (1.0 : 1.6 : 2.2 ratios) and such but it does require a lot of power to achieve realistic sound levels. With seating starting just in front of the projector (30 degree viewing angle) the sweet spot for good surround audio is fairly large. Despite it's size though it's still surprising how quickly you run out of spots to put seats when a few friends come around to watch a movie.